Categories
Reflection

Life; and Other Quartets

What end do they reach anyway,

What fruit do they bear anyway,
Of seeds, for leaves, is the story,
What do roots hope for anyway.

Of all the thoughts that breathe of you,
Of all the breaths that think of you,
I think I want to live the most,
The one that makes me one with you.

Wretched and hurting to the core,
Pray why should I breathe more?
No one waiting, no waiting for,
Would this just be or is there more?

Waiting to see the back of the strings,
The ones that tie me to the fringe.
Waiting for the day when soul does all,
Draw my moves and free my seams

And then she looked at me from far,
Oh it was good to be thus far.
Waiting to stop in vain for long,
Tells me just how near is all far.


I don’t know what it is, what it will be,
But this once I’ll let it be what it will be.
What have I got that I ever prayed for?
So this once I’ll let it be what it will be.

Was a dream that brought him to me,
Was a dream that took me to him.
Till he wanted me to be him,
Till I wanted him to be me.

Let one little evening not spoil the day,
Let one little evening not spoil the day,
I hear and again and wonder aloud,
Doesn’t the evening make it a lovely day?

Ever seen a pallor that flays,
A heart full of love that says,
Shunning the one that cares,
Pity thy fear, I pity your ways.

One more moment has changed its name. Yet,
Wonder if the moment ever lives by a name.
Would it speak for anything else, or,
Would my love for you be the same?

Categories
Journalism

Life is in the Air

You would be reading this three days before Uttarayan if you’ve brought this copy from a newsstand. But if you’re a League subscriber, reading the story might just give you a sense of it being a post-script; what with the day having gone by a couple of days ago. Luckily, League has never been about ‘breaking news’ the much abuse phrase of our times. As ever, the endeavour is to realise a fact or two while having fun.

So, what is Makar Sankranti, the day which we celebrate by going berserk over rooftops, flying kites?

Makar Sankranti – also known or pronounced as Makar Sankrant – is an auspicious day based on the movement of the Sun (Surya). ‘Makar’  refers to ‘Makara rashi’ – the zodiac corresponding to Capricorn. ‘Sankranti’ in Sanskrit means ‘to cross into’ or the day when sun enters from one zodiac sign to another. So Makar Sankranti is the day when the sun enters into the zodiac Capricorn. It is also known as Uttarayana Punyakalam or the entry of sun into the Northern Hemisphere. The six-month long Uttarayana begins on this day.

Makara Sankranti is celebrated on January 14th in the Hindu month of Magh. Hindu calendar is based on the movement of the moon and therefore it is a lunar calendar. Hence the change in the date of various celebrations with corresponding English Calendar. But Makarasankranti is based on solar movement and therefore it has a fixed day.
Makar Sankranti is of great significance to a devote Hindu. Lord Surya (Sun God) is worshiped on this day. Every living and non-living being merges with the Brahman and Sun is the Pratyaksha-Brahman or the Brahman that can be seen.
The importance of Sun to earth and to the living beings was understood by Hindus from the very beginning. And the importance of it can be found in the Gayatri Mantra chanted to Sun (Surya) daily.

There is also a symbolic meaning to Makara Sankranti. ‘Makar’ means crocodile. Sankranti means ‘to cross into or change.’ The ‘Makara’ or crocodile represents the materialistic world and ‘Sankranti’ gives an opportunity to get away from the clutches of the crocodile or the materialistic world.

The six month long Uttarayana begins on the Makar Sankrant day. From this day, the harshness of winter subsidizes and the days get longer. Symbolically, the Sun slowly removes darkness and ushers in the light of knowledge.
Uttarayana is also the daytime of the Devas and therefore auspicious activities takes place during this period.

There are also numerous legends and myths which add to the importance of Makara Sankranti.
One of the most important myths is the death of Bhisma Pitamaha in the Mahabharata. Bhisma chose Makarasankranti day to die. (Bhisma had got a boon from his father that he will only die when he wishes.) It is believed that people who die during Uttarayana merges with the Brahman, thus ending the cycle of rebirth.

Legend also has it that Lord Vishnu buried Asuras on this day beneath the Mandara Mountain. It signifies the end of evil and the dawn of righteousness.

Another legend is that King Bhageeratha brought Ganges down into Patala on Makara Sankranti day. This was to get salvation to his ancestors who were cursed by Sage Kapila and turned into ashes. On this day millions of people take bath in the Ganges. Makara Sankranti is also an important bathing date during Kumbh Mela and Magh Mela.

Puranas state that on Makar Sankranti day, Surya (Sun) visits Lord Shani. According to mythology Lord Shani, is the son of Surya.

Since Makara Sankranti is associated with Surya (Sun God), the best way to start the day, believed by many, is by reciting the Gayatri Mantra.

It is believed that Lord Surya visits his son Lord Shani on this day, irrespective of their difference in opinions. Therefore many people make it a point to visit their sons and buy them gifts. It is also a day to forgive past quarrels and start afresh.

The six month long Uttarayana begins on the Makar Sankrant day. From this day, the harshness of winter subsidizes and the days get longer. Symbolically, the Sun slowly removes darkness and ushers in the light of knowledge.

Sweets and dishes made out of Sesame oil (Til) are served on this day. Sweets made out of Til is exchanged as mark of friendship. The symbolic meaning is to emulate the quality of Tilgul – to stick together even in adversity. Rice meal is the order of the day in Bihar, Jharkhand and is some parts of Uttar Pradesh.

Throughout India Makar Sankrati is in a way associated with harvest. So people pray for a good harvest on this day. Cows – which is an integral part of agriculture – is bathed and worshipped. Another important aspect is ‘Daan’ or Charity. Charity does not merely confirm to money but a person donates what he/she is able to like food, Moong Dal, rice, ghee, Til etc.

In Maharashtra, sweets made out of Til  are exchanged between friends and relatives. Married women in Maharashtra apply Haldi-Kumkum on each others’ forehead.

In Rajasthan, especially in Jaipur, the most important event is the kite flying.

In Uttar Pradesh and people living along the banks of Ganga takes a dip in the river on this day and offer prayers to Sun God.

Makar Sankranti is celebrated throughout India in different names:

  • In Tamil Nadu, Makar Sankranti is celebrated as Pongal – a harvest festival.
  • In Andhra Pradesh, it is Pedda Panduga – a harvest festival – and is celebrated for four days.
  • In Kerala, Makar Sankranti marks the end of the pilgrimage to the famous Sabarimala Temple.
  • In West Bengal, it is Pithey parban – a harvest festival – and there is also the famous Ganga Sagar mela.
  • In Assam, it is Bhogali Bihu.
  • In Punjab, Jammu and in some parts of Himachal Pradesh and Haryana, it is Lohri.
  • In Central India, it is Sakarat.
  • In Orissa, it is Makar Mela.

Clearly, Makar Sankranti is a festival that is celebrated throughout the nation. And the diversity in the methods of celebration of the same festival is what makes India such a fascinating country. To a foreigner, the country would look like a collage of cultures woven together by a common thread.

During last year’s ‘Patangotsav’ as a part of the Vibrant Gujarat Summit, the Gujarat government had posted the following description of the occassion, probably for the international participants, on the festival home page:

“Uttarayan, or Makara Sankranti is traditionally believed to be the starting point of the Sun’s northward journey.
“When Sun enters the orbit of a rashi from another, it is called sankranti . Sun moves in the orbit of a rashi for a month. In the month of paush , the sun enters the orbit of Makara (Capricorn); and thus the day is celebrated as ‘Makara Sankranti ‘.

The day of Uttarayan has special importance and is regarded as very auspicious. It is also believed that the Gods sleep for six months closing the doors of heaven, which open at the entrance of the sun in northern zone, i.e. in the orbit of Makara , when the Gods awake from a long slumber.

Uttarayan also has a significant relationship with the agricultural economy of the state. By this time, the Kharif crops are ready and are brought home. In an economy which is purely agricultural, domestic animals are not forgotten and grass is freely distributed to the village cattle. Uttarayan, thus, becomes a harvest festival in the true sense of the term.”

_________________________________________________________

When did it all start?

The kites of history can be traced back thousands of years to when kites first originated in China.

The initial usage of kites was purely military: they were a communication tool. Different messages were communicated mainly via different colored kites during the day. At night, the message communicated was very limited in comparison to those during the day because the lanterns carried by the kite could not produce different lights.

In extremely rare occasions, giant kites carrying aerial observers were also deployed in reconnaissance roles.

Gradually, kites became a popular form of recreation as well as art. With the advent of gunpowder, kites were occasionally flown for bombing missions after the Yuan Dynasty, delivering explosives to targets that were out of reach of cannons and arrows, such as those on the opposite slope of a mountain.

_________________________________________________________

Ahmedabad’s goldmine digging dust:

Courtesy Bhanubhai Shah, Ahmedabad had the privilege of having an excitingly unique museum – a kite museum in the year 1987. Alas, like most heritage treasure across the nation, the museum did not take too long to become a dungeon of non-maintenance. In fact, it should come as a surprise if any common Amdavadi can claim to know of even the museum’s existence!

Quite heartbreakingly for Bhanubhai, the museum had been donated the best of his 50 year-old collection. Apart from kites, many useful information nuggets too had formed a part of the museum.

Sample this:

Kite was born in China in 200 BC

The NY Tribune had used kites to display results of the 1896 Presidential elections

Categories
Writing

First Kitli Market Survey By Kitli Times

It clearly is the season of brand building exercise for Ahmedabad. With billboards across the city showing some celebrity or the other either listening to or saying something into a symbolic microphone-cum-earpiece, how could the Kitli have stayed untouched by all the excitement?

So it was decided that we will put up a questionnaire at a few select Kitlis across the city. We announced that the best answer would to each question would get an addhee cha and bun-maska from League magazine. With such amazing jackpot of a prize, the response was, as expected, fantastic.

We present the questions and the best answers, along with the names of the winners. Read on and get a pulse of what Ahmedabad feels … about itself.


What do you think of Ahmedabad?

Amdavad etle lehar, paani ane bhajiya. In sort, bhaad mein jaye duniya, hum bajayein harmoniya.
(Vipul Maniar, Sales, Telecom)

Is Ahmedabad a global city?
Etle? (meaning?)
(Prashant Desai, Student)

Should prohibition be relaxed?
What difference does it make anyway. In fact, purely from the consumer’s point of view, I would be happy if it is not. Without the taxes, it costs less!

On a serious note, I don’t think it should be. Life is beautiful without it too. In fact, I pity those who say that they can’t dance in a disc till they have a drink. And as for business, I think Gujarat is doing well without the revenue out of liquor.
(B Suresh, Techie.)

[We would like to ask B Sureh one thing: Are you always this serious? :-)]

How do you compare Ahmedabad with Bangalore and Hyderabad?
No comparison. They are better. They have IT industry.
(Vikas Arora, student)

Badha harkaj chhe. (Each is on an equal footing) India nu kaain na thaai. (There’s not much hope for India)
(Jignesh Gala, Tour  operator)

Which one thing defines our city?
Etle? (meaning?)
(Prashant Desai, Student)

I think business, garba and safety for women.
(Ritesh Kriplani, businessman)
[Where did you learn your math Ritesh? We had asked for one thing.]

What would Ahmedabad be like in the year 2020?
Everything would be the same. You would be asking us the same questions. We would be giving you the same answers.
(B Suresh, Techie.)

More traffic, more flyovers; even more traffic, even more flyovers; even more traffic, no more flyovers.
(Hitesh Khandwala, MD)

Alya, aatlu duur nu na vicharai.
(Vipul Maniar, Sales, Telecom)

When we had started, we’d thought that six questions would not be enough and it would not give us the complete picture. But as you just read, we’ve got a load-full from the kitli junta. The message is clear, either talk for the heck of talking something. Anything. Or just get down to work.

[Was that for us by any chance?]

You never know what you can hit upon at an Amdavadi Kitli. The KT team was recently at a kitli near Nehru Nagar when it hit upon a Kitli Poet (KP). Don’t look for John Keats here and you would be happy.

Woh Amdavad Hai Mera

Jahan gaai aur bhens
beech sadak pe
roz banaye ghera
woh amdavad hai mera
woh amdavad hai mera

Jahaan khadi bike pe
Ulte hokar,
Log milayen naina
Woh amdavad hai mera
Woh amdavad hai mera

Jahaan gali, gali mein
chaa ki kitli
karti hai basera
woh amdavad hai mera
woh amdavad hai mera

jahaan har diwal ko
paan ki pichkaari
karti hai rangeela
woh amdavad hai mera
woh amdavad hai mera

Jahan hall ko hole
Aur mall ko mole
Bolein bhai aur behna
Woh amdavad hai mera
Woh amdavad hai mera

Jahan kinetic pe
May aur June mein
Dikhein kewal naina
Woh amdavad hai mera
Woh amdavad hai mera

Jaha zor zor se
Chillakar ke
Khana ek kala hai
Woh amdavad hai mera
Woh amdavad hai mera

Categories
Cinema Journalism

Don, Don na Raha, Paan, Paan na Raha!

It is not about doing justice to an existing classic or improving upon an average film. The big question here is if it is possible to replicate the emotions of an audience of yesteryear?

It takes innocence, enthusiasm, devotion, courage and craft to make a film that is essentially a tribute to that one piece of magic on celluloid, which was instrumental in making one, a filmmaker in the first place. Don, in a way, was one such cinematic exercise. So was Akira Kurosawa’s Yojimbo (1960), which was known to have emulated a the westerns made by John Ford.

What is of greater interest to us, however, is the subject of remakes and not the makers of them.

The concept of remake is hardly a novel one. Ben-Hur was made three times (1907, 1925, 1959) – with the last version being the most successful in terms of Oscars (11) and box-office collections ($37 million); both ‘editions’ of The Ten Commandments (1926, 1925) were equally successful.

However not all remakes have been successful. There have been less-than-flattering reinterpretations of existing classics at times by the makers of the original themselves! But we shall skip the dead bodies and their gory post-mortems here.

The point, however, is that much as one would want to look beyond the subject of remakes, it would have to be accepted by all that remakes can’t simply be dismissed with one firm brush of disdain. For, to begin with, they help the world remember (or learn about) the originals and secondly, not much of art can qualify as creation sans inspiration anyway. For instance, there have been innumerable films based on Shakespearean tales, but shockingly  enough, the plot of Hamlet is said to have been borrowed by Shakespeare from his Elizabethan predecessors!

Indian cinema, theater and music have always drawn generously from mythological and folk tales of our inspiringly diverse culture groups. In fact, the folk music and dance forms too draw some of their present inspirations from popular culture – as propagated by films and music – of the present times.

With time, culture and the various forms of its expression too change. Old traditions might wear a trendy new garb, while new beginnings might be copiously influenced by ancient traditions.

So then, does that mean that all the cinema of present times is basically based on some earlier tales, and hence remakes?

The answer may be both ‘yes’ and ‘no’. Yes, there is a probability of their being based – knowingly or otherwise – on some ancient tale of some land. Yet, no, they cannot be called remakes merely on the basis of the extreme  probability.

In any case, we are here concerned with the scenario of a film-maker himself calling his film a remake of the earlier one.
But why call it a remake? Why not give it the description, ‘based on the original’?

After all, except for Gus Van Sant’s Psycho (1998), which was a ‘verbatim’, shot-on-shot replication of Alfred Hitchcock’s 1960 original, most remakes make many changes in the narrative – including that of addition or removal of characters, change in the mood of the narrative or that of simply placing the narrative in a completely different era. What better example can we give than that of Devdas, which was played in their inimitable styles by K L Saigal, Dilip Kumar and Shah Rukh Khan – not to mention the distinct styles of directors like Bimal Roy and Sanjay Leela Bhansali.
Sensibility of a film, the emotions that it generates in the audience and the feel of its era are all inseparable parts of the magic called cinema. Once a film starts feeling different from its earlier avatar, one can safely assume it to be a different film!

One can remake Dil Chahta Hai with three female protagonists, based in Darbhanga (Bihar) in year 1863 and make an equally compelling and entertaining film at that; but would that be a ‘remake of Dil Chahta Hai’? Ram Gopal Varma might end up making a film that is technically superior and just as entertaining as Sholay, but would that film ever make you feel like the 1975 one?

So why not acknowledge the inspiration, have a different name of the new one and make what you are making anyway? You would not only avoid disappointing the loyals and team of the earlier one because of making changes (as in Farhan Akhtar’s DON) but also be saving yourself from mind-numbing expectations and, God forbid, soul-scarring criticism.
But hey, wouldn’t that steal away some ready-made publicity and respect? Of course. Which else motive do you think is muddying the subject of remakes?

…      …      …

A Tale of Two Psychos

One of the very rare remakes of its kind, Gus Van Sant’s Psycho (1998) was a ‘verbatim’, shot-by-shot replication of Alfred Hitchcock’s 1960 original. Almost all frames of the cult original were recreated in the exact same manner, with almost the same dialogue, the same music, and even the same screenwriter! Predictably, even before the release of the film, stringent critics were already questioning the purpose of ‘such a remake’ of ‘such a classic’.

In the DVD commentary of Psycho, Van Sant claims that his remake should be seen more as an artistic endeavour and not a commercial one. And that one of the leading motivation for him was to make the original more appealing to the youth of the present time. He further corroborates in the commentary that the original Psycho was filmed in black-and-white, not a very attractive medium in itself, and carried a language that might be deemed archaic now.

While one can argue that huge films like Schindler’s List have recently been made in black & white because of the requirement of the script, one can understand Van Sant’s slant towards the colour medium. After all, how easy is for any of us to think of making a film in black & white today? Unfortunately for Van Sant though, the very decision of giving colour to the original contributed to a great extent towards the spectacular failure of the remake. Psychological thrillers are supposed to be grim and ‘shadowy’, not a collage of pastel colours.

All said and psyched, no one quite understood the whole point of replicating a milestone of a story-board. Especially when access to the original is as convenient as it actually is? And what about the whole factor of time that this write-up is all about? How could Van Sant not take into account the change in sensibilities of the audiences of two different times, before serving the same dish, with minor modifications?

In all, this was one remake that made headlines for all the wrong reasons. And this was one remake that most filmmakers would vouch of not attempting. Cinema is basically about narrating a story. Not about playing the same live voice through a audio player. Ouch!

Categories
Journalism

Will we get Wal-Marted?

A lot of American Companies may have got ‘Bangalored’, but one US Company can more than manage to give it backto India is Wal-Mart. Recent deal between the ‘behemoth of Bentonville (Arkansas)’ and Indian telecom major Bhartimay just give it the elbow to enter the fastest growing market of the world. And it is making a lot of people nervous.

Ahmedabad, and indeed the whole of India, is gripped by an unprecedented retail mania. Both cultivable land at the countryside and housing colonies bang in the middle of blustling metropolises are being purchased lock, stock and two brimming barrels. But no news has been bigger than the recent signing of accord between India’s Bharti Group and the world’s biggest retail chain, Wal-Mart.

The deal is said to combine Bharti’s understanding of India, its reach within the higher echelons of the Delhi durbar and an existing database of consumers with Wal-Mart’s unparalleled business model of buying big and selling for cheaper to the biggest chunk of markets, anywhere that it goes.

Before we get down to what it means to us, let’s throw a little light on the behemoth of Bentonville.

It doesn’t get bigger than this:

Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. was founded by Sam Walton in 1962. It is the largest retailer in the world, and the second largest corporation (behind Exxon Mobil). Wal-Mart reported net income of $11.2 billion on $316 billion of sales revenue. It is the largest  private employer in the United States and Mexico; largest grocery retailer in the United States, with an estimated 20 percent of the retail grocery and consumables business, and the largest toy seller in the United States, with an estimated 45 percent of the retail toy business! Eat that, competition.

Internationally, Wal-Mart operates in Mexico as Walmex, in the United Kingdom as ASDA and in Japan as The Seiyu Co., Ltd. Also, wholly owned operations are located in Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Puerto Rico, and the United Kingdom.  Wal-Mart’s international operations account for approximately twenty percent of its  total sales.

…      …      …

Do these help form a picture for you?

  • Wal-mart customers place low prices and value as the most  important reason for shopping at Wal-Mart.
  • Wal-Mart customers are sensitive to higher utility costs and gas (petrol / diesel) prices
  • In the US, Wal-Mart customer’s average incomes are below the national average.
  • More than one-fifth of Wal-Mart’s US customers have no bank accounts, twice the national rate.
  • Wal-Mart stores, as the company, has yet to significantly penetrate Major urban areas in US.

…      …      …

There’s one for everyone:

Wal-Mart Stores Division U.S. is Wal-Mart’s largest business subsidiary, accounting for 67.2% of fiscal 2006 net sales. This segment consists of three traditional retail formats: discount stores, Super Centers, and neighborhood markets, all of which are located in the United States, as well as Wal-Mart’s online retailer, walmart.com.

Wal-Mart Stores operates retail department stores selling a range of non-grocery products, though emphasis is now focused on the Super centers, which include more grocery items.

In the US, there are 1092 Discount Stores,  2,195  Super-centers & 110 Neighborhood Markets.

…      …      …

Duur Ka Jhatka Paas Mein Laga?

Did the Bharti-Wal-Mart deal cause the recent development of Reliance Industries finalising the buying of Adani Retail, the Ahmedabad-based retail arm of the Rs. 13,500 crore Adani Group?

While the two happenings may seem disjoint, especially since Adani retail is a profitable venture – with the topline of around Rs. 200 crore – of the Adanis, industry sources suggest that the fact of the matter is that retail does not form the core business of the Adani Group and hence it made sense for the group to exit the business while the market is doing well. With Reliance scouting acquisitions with a vengeance, Adanis could also demand, and get, a significant premium over the actual valuation. With 54 stores in different formats, and successful ones at that, Adani has reasons strong enough to negotiate from a position of respectable strength too, irrespective of the size of the Mega suitor.

But what gave birth to the speculations about the proposed deal was the timing of it – just about the time of the signing of the Bharti-Wal-Mart deal. Reliance may not lose too much sleep about the existing competition, but the Bharti-Wal-Mart behemoth would be a tough cookie even for India’s biggest private sector company. And hence the urgency towards preparing a robust ground. Probably.

Or maybe not. But Bharti-Wal-Mart is menacing enough to  cause similar upheavals in Ahmedabad / India.

…      …      …

Battleground Ahmedabad:

The city is acknowledged by many in the industry as the best ‘research laboratory’ for retail operations in India! Once you crack the ultra-price-sensitive Ahmedabad market, things only get easier in other parts of the nation.

Consequently, there is no doubt whatsoever that Ahmedabad would figure prominently in Bharti-Wal-Mart scheme of things, even at the planning stage.

Presently, the Future Group (Big Bazaar, Pantaloon etc), Star Bazaar (TATA), Adani and Pyramid are a few of the major names fighting out in the Ahmedabad market. Reliance is soon going to open its account at SG Highway, after winning the battle in court against Shoppers Stop for huge space at the upcoming ISKON mall. Giving them company in ample measure are Subhiksha and new Super Value Store chain by HLL, which is trying to safeguard its bottom-line by empowering the neighbourhood kirana stores. In fact, that effort by HLL is the single biggest, if not the only, life-support-kit for the neighbourhood stores. The question is, will even HLL’s support be enough to fight the onslaught of an all-out war between the Future Group, Reliance and Bharti-Wal-Mart? Well, the jury is still out. Whatever may be the outcome, we hope not too many people lose their livelihoods.

Challenges for Ahmedabad:

When planning new store locations, Wal-Mart often faces many concerns from the affected communities. Local critics that oppose new Wal-Mart store openings cite concerns such as traffic problems, environment problems, public safety, absentee land-lordism, bad public relations, low wages and benefits, and predatory pricing.

Can Ahmedabad take any more traffic / parking burden? Wouldn’t the natural greenery – of whatever magnitude – of the countryside get trampled under the war for square foots? Can Ahmedabad afford to have any more jobless, aimless and hence dangerous slum population that has been pushed out of business by the retail biggies?

These are certain questions that only time can tell. Not all of the concerns may actually translate in to reality anytime in the next year or two. But, as instances across the globe have showed, when biggies fight, a lot social churning takes place too. Add to that the fragile caste and religion dynamics of the society, and you can imagine the upheaval that it might cause.

But it’s only a competition between a couple of big business houses, right?

Yes, it’s only about competition for market share between companies whose combined wealth can feed a couple of small countries of the world for years! And at that scale, anything goes. Environment, land acquisition and resources utilisation may hit the headlines for all the wrong reasons. For, unlike IT, retailing by these companies would involve farmers, transporters, service industry professionals and of course consumers.

And any activity that involves most sections of a society has the ability to affect most others too. Many cities have found that out the hard way.

And now the good news:

When companies like Bharti-Wal-Mart and Reliance set up their shop in your city, you can expect anyone from your grandmother to your dog to get employment in some form – either directly or indirectly. Hence, Ahmedabad can really look forward to creation of hundreds, if not thousands, of jobs because of the retail war.

Buying of commodities might become not just comfortable, but a lot cheaper. Overall work ethic of the city might improve because of the replication of the ‘customer first’ model of retail giants. And with products from across the world being promised to be stacked, the quality of life would get enhanced too.

All in all, if the negatives are kept under check – which well might be, what with Bharti being the operator here – getting Wal-Marted might not be such a bad thing to happen. Which city doesn’t want more jobs, more choices, less prices – all under one roof?

But hey, it might just be too early to even speculate about things to come. In any case, Reliance is going to enter the market first – with or without Adani retail in its dish. A few months with it, and we’ll get a picture of how things would pan out from there on. For the moment, wait with bated breath for the retail war of the century.

Near 200-ft ring road, Ahmedabad?

If Bharti and Wal-Mart replicate the formats that the latter have been so successful with over the years, we might see a lot of activity around the 200-ft ring road and other peripheries of the city. Simply because the average size of a Wal-Mart discount store is about   102,000 square feet, while that of the supercenter is 261,000 square feet. The smallest format, the neighbourhood store takes an average of 42,000 square feet. With the Future Group and Reliance too fighting for the same formats, there might not be enough space for Bharti-Wal-Mart within city, by the time it arrives in around Aug. 2007.

With players like Tesco (UK) getting itchy to get into fray – possibly with a tie-up with the TATAs, land within city would be hard to come by. Also, with the SG Highway – Gandhinagar belt promising to become the IT corridor of Gujarat, townships by Sahara and Adani apart from a host of other activities in and around the 200-ft ring road, the place may become the showcase place for all the majors – with scaled-down versions of the same mushrooming in the rest of the city.

What it would also do is add to the mushrooming of schools like DPS / Calorx, edutainment centers like Science City and upscale residential colonies around the place, which in turn would give further reason for the retail majors to scale up their presence in the area.

The big question then would be the issue of development of the area by authorities. Would it become a showcase like the Bandra-Kurla corridor of Mumbai or would it be another Bopal of our own city? Would people who flock every new and major retail centers from all parts of the city (and neighbouring towns) bring just revenue or would gift the area with never-ending traffic snarls (what with it also being the highway)? Would the locality love the cousins of Sam Walton or would they rather have their kirana store back?

Categories
Journalism

We’ve Got to Find a Thread

Ahmedabad has not had too much good written about it since long. But that’s not the most distressing part of sorry picture. What should hurt all of us more is that we don’t speak too much good about ourselves either. There is virtually no collective compassion for the city. Not the kind that has been or can be expressed aloud anyway.
Unfortunately, where’s the encouragement from either the political authorities or any of the social groups, including the charity-oriented wings of big corporate houses?

Now sample this: Almost anyone who is exposed to images from the US has probably seen t-shirts that read ‘I Love NY’, with the lovable symbol of heart replacing the word ‘love’. Do you know who is responsible for the almost cult logo? The authority behind the enviable statement of New Yorkers is a state body that not only has a boringly long name but also has got nothing too much to do with arts – New York State Department of Economic Development.

Shouldn’t we, citizens of the principal city of one of India’s most commerce-oriented state get the message loud and clear from that? It is in Ahmedabad’s economic interests, apart from a host of other enriching ones, to initiate a compassion drive that gives us all a sense of ownership with regards the city. And which,  consequently, prods us to become more caring and nurturing. Why aren’t the ‘city fathers’ (sic) waking up this very simple argument?

Fortunately, not everyone is waiting for that miracle from our moribund bureaucracy. Ahmedabad Management Association (AMA), that fantastically proactive organisation, had embarked on a mission similar to that of the NYSDED. Under the guidance of a former chief of Mudra Communications, the organisation had come up with a logo for the city of Ahmedabad, with ‘From Mills To Malls’ being the catch phrase of the idea. This author is not aware of the absolute work and team behind the initiative; but the unfortunate fact of the matter is that neither the logo nor the slogan has managed to permeate the core of the city thus far. A part of the reason can be that while the logo is tad difficult for a common man to recreate, the catch phrase has not caught on as yet either. But it has been a exercise worth wholesome praise. Hopefully, it would give birth to many such initiative from other concerned groups.

And it is necessary. Just as you need to feel one with fellow shoulders in a trench, while fighting the enemy, it helps a great deal to have smiling and singing pals while painting a new house. It helps the spirits, makes work enjoyable and takes much less time to finish. And even if it takes long, you don’t mind, for you’re having a nice time anyway!

And that spirit is precisely what every great city is about, and what they should be. That can happen only when there is a single thread tying every heart of the society. A thread that you can see and help to pull everyone together. A thread that is simple at heart and even simpler to express. We’ve got to find a thread. Now.